Back to ATRL
This is
Classic ATRL
, an interactive archive of our original website.
Music News
Charts
Videos
Celebria
Base
The Lounge
Best Of
YTT
Games
TRL Archive
User Name
Remember Me
Password
Members who joined ATRL prior to 2017, sign in here.
Any changes made to your password do not sync.
Classic ATRL
>
Base
>
Poll: New York, New York: Beyoncé vs Lady Gaga
Sign In
Poll: New York, New York: Beyoncé vs Lady Gaga
View Poll Results
: Better rendition?
Beyoncé
13
43.33%
Lady Gaga
17
56.67%
Voters:
30
. You may not vote on this poll
Last Post
Actions
AxelFox
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 5,843
Thread Starter
|
Post #1
New York, New York: Beyoncé vs Lady Gaga
Who gave a better rendition of the iconic song?
Queen B:
or Lady G
ScarletWitch
Member Since: 4/3/2014
Posts: 7,895
Post #2
Gaga by far
Rusty
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 16,371
Post #3
This one is Gaga for me.
Ash12345
Member Since: 6/30/2012
Posts: 22,003
Post #4
Woah, I'm actually in awe. Beyonce was so unbelievable gorgeous.
Rumbler
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 1,975
Post #5
Beyonce tbh.
Gaga always sings like she has a **** in her mouth.
EtherealCat
Member Since: 5/27/2016
Posts: 1,840
Post #6
Gaga, I prefer Christina's to both of these though.
HandsOn
Member Since: 6/1/2011
Posts: 10,384
Post #7
I don't like the arrangement on Bey's performance
at all
, so Gaga.
BadMonster
Member Since: 1/1/2013
Posts: 15,264
Post #8
Gaga's voice, power, tone, performance, style all far exceed Beyonce's forgettable and boring performance of this song
HonourableVomit
Member Since: 8/27/2011
Posts: 13,026
Post #9
I've never liked Beyonce's attempts at Broadway, not her forté at all.
MrBeyonceFan
Member Since: 6/22/2011
Posts: 20,940
Post #10
Bey actually is more natural and adding her own fresh R&B elements
Legend lol
Natawie
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 2,465
Post #11
Gaga.
Misguided Ghost
Member Since: 1/5/2014
Posts: 602
Post #12
Lady Gaga.
Her voice fits the song more.
Click Clack
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 2/6/2014
Posts: 32,692
Post #13
The Legend.
Otter
Member Since: 5/27/2016
Posts: 1,477
Post #14
Gaga has better breath control here and her performance is better. Her tone is a pit pantomime but I guess thats perfect for this sort of song.
Jet
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 46,848
Post #15
Bey's was terrible. Her voice was so shrill and quivery during the DIL era. Gaga by default.
Actions for this Thread
Print this Thread
"Absolute TRL" 1999-2006; "Popfusion" 2006-2007; "ATRL" 2007-present