I think she's a more a performer than a musician. She can dance and sing well which make her a performer. Discuss

She's an absolute musician and has lots of involvement in the vocal and production stages of her songs and albums. + she mastered and uses her voice like (hardly) no other in the industry.

ATRL will obviously shade in this thread though. No matter how many producers and songwriters confirm her big contributions to the songs, harmonies, instrumentals, melodies and lyrics. So it's no use telling that over and over again

No.

Yes, a very talented one

Both

More a performer, but still both.

Nope.

Nope

I think the only true musicians in the pop world are lady gaga, Taylor and Alicia Keys. I might be forgetting a few.

That gif

Not really. I see her more creative director + entertainer, dancer, vocalist. like Madonna.

Yes.

She's everything

I would rather call her an incredible vocalist. The voice is her instrument.

Nah, she is an interpreter, entertainer and a brand to sell stuff other people came up with.

No.

It's like beating a dead horse at this point.

She can't write, produce or play instruments so I'd say no.

Anyone can sing when there's material being written for them, but it doesn't make them a musician to the core. It's kinda insulting to real artists, especially those who are a triple threat (people who are able to do what I've said on the first sentence).

she is both

Of course she's a virtuoso