Uh, this is not Entertainment Weekly's review. This is some website called "Blast." Also, EW gives letter grades, not stars. Their review (done by Michael Slezak), which gave the album a C, can be found here: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20441003,00.html
"Throughout the record, DeWyze doesn't just flirt with the use of tired clichés; he takes them out to dinner, picks up the bill, and drives then home at the end of the evening."