Which of these 2 vocally gifted legends have/had the more iconic career?

Whitney times a billion...

Next question?

Mariah >>>>

Whitney, give Mimi more time.

This thread has been made several times already... People are obviously going to vote for Whitney...

simple question
whitney

Whitney

The voice Whitney Houston

Whitney. Most iconic vocalist of all time, along with Aretha Franklin. Mariah is up there though.

It s unfair cus Whitney is dead and we all know artists become way more iconic when they pass.
When people asked that question 2 years ago on this board Mariah was ALWAYS winning and people kept talking about how irrelevant whitney had become, how she had ruined her career and legacy, and what a washed up has been she was and so on...

mimi

She did have to have a mental breakdown though.

Anyway, I feel like Mariah's probably should be recognized as that. But, people in general don't acknowledge it as iconic, so I think Whitney is the right answer

We're talking about career not personal lives and death.

MC

mimi

Neither did Whitney. She also didn't have to marry her boss for it to happen either.

I knew that was going to come up LOL