Just want to hear opinions! They both are/were successful but who is the better singer?

Hilary Duff:


Selena Gomez:

Hilary. I am going to wait for one of Selena's fans to post that edited Radio Disney performance though. OP, you didn't even post Hilary's best performance.

Hilary

I took this performance cause the OP said it was live! Which is her best though?

This was obviously started by a lovatic for people to shade Selena but aside from the point, although I like Selena's tone better and with practice she could be very good, Hilary's performances are more consistent. So Hilary.

that's not true, not for Lovaticful.

__

And i think they're both okay.. I think Selena had her moments, good and bad ones
I do think they could both do MUCH better though, especially Selena if she was less nervous.

I like Selena's tour performances better than Hilary's but the award shows, not so much

Hilary I love Selena though.

Since this thread is about the better singer I will let that one stand BUT this is overall one of her better performances, she gives it her everything, the dancing is not the best but oh well:

agree. The EMA one was really good though!

Oh and i think her "More" performance on that NYE show was really decent!

forgot to add a poll Can I edit this..?

not really, I wanted to hear opinions. you know that I like Selena

For me selena idk y but i don't even like studio versions of hilary her voice sounds monotonous and i find her notes flats No emotions nothing (no shading its just my personal opinion )

hilary!!!

This. I dont see the meaning of this thread....

How could i choose between these two flawless princess?

It's too early for me to really go in how I want to.

Clearly you have not listened to all of her studio albums if you think that she shows no emotions when she sings.

I can't decide

i think they both have their qualities. Personally i find Hilary's tone extremely interesting.
I think both of them could be way better if they would do vocal training!

True i have listened her debut album that's it and on that basis i am judging them i mean in selena debut album she clearly showed the emotions well its not that i don't like hilary songs its just i don't like the way she sings

Hilary did vocal training when she was pregnant.

this is great though