I say Avril tbh,



She was larger than life and started the anti Britney pop rock revolution.

Christina of course.

Pink has sort of stolen Avrils thunder

Avril is still relevant in Japan. Is Christina?


But really, I don't know. They're about the same, aren't they?

Is this really a question?

Yeah that's what I was thinking. Isn't Avril obviously still a bigger and more influential artist than Christina?! I mean going by their last eras, Avril could still tour, sold 1.5 million albums, had a WW top 10 hit, and didn't need to resort to judging on a ****** talent show. Why is this even a poll?

Who is Avril influencing?
We're suddenly bringing up WW numbers now yet talking about a USA show?
Her last album was in the 300k range along with Bionic. And she actually had a single that did okay ok radio. So in terms of current success shes about the same if not less.

They're about the same. But Complicated might have more impact than anything in Christina's discography, to be honest (except for Beautiful).

[QUOTE=atrlster;13341563]Who is Avril influencing?

Avril made people like michelle branch, the donnas, etc happen.

Avril's debut was more impactful , "Let go" sold 16M copies while aguilera's debut sold 13M

And avril's debut was WW while xtina's debut was mild outse US / canada.

Through the years avril had more impact as well.

Avrils 3rd album "TBDT" sold more than Xtinas 3rd album "B2B"

And avril's 4th album "GL" sold more than Xtina's 4th album "Bionic"

She's currently influencing the likes of Taylor Swift.

Well the show has to be located in a certain country? It's hardly a WW show.. what kind of comment

WW >>>> US. US is just a market and Xtina is tryna get her WW numbers up by being on The Voice but no is here for it, while 1.5 million people are here for Avril and 62 date tour as well Christina literally could never. In fact Goodbye Lullaby outsold her last two eras by two times COMBINED

Sorry but redundant question with no debatable answer. Avril is the only right answer here

I was trying to be gracious to Xtina by including Beautiful even though we all know Complicated has had more impact/is more remembered by the GP.

Burlesque sold 700k in usa tho

Avril

That is a movie soundtrack, not a Christina album. Lemme go get the receipts to Eragon soundtrack, One Piece Z film soundtrack and the Alice and Wonderland soundtrack and combine the efforts to annihilate Xtina completely then.....,... hmmmmm... SIT, and use some proper receipts and stop being a basic hoe reaching receipts that don't even belong to Xtina but a movie. So sad you Xtina fans

All the singles, bar Losing Grip, from Let Go are more memorable than any Xtina track. They'll have to deal

Sales have a barely nonexistent effect on impact, even in that point Aguilera's sales are higher pushing her to the over 100 million records sold mark where Avril hasn't gone yet, and Avril doesn't even have a globally massively large single to top that off, while X's got 2 - http://www.mediatraffic.de/alltime-track-chart.htm

Xtina's inspired Avril's look, persona, and musical style in pop rock so it's obvious the legend holds much greater impact.