They come off as ****s is the problem. They looked like girls on the show (minus the performances) and now they appear as less capable PCD-clones. Their entire image is force-fed by Robin Antin and manufactured. I don't like them all that much.
Have you seen the video? (I can't say I don't like it), but it's the girl's dancing around in a boxing ring, wearing, well basically nothing. (Hot? yes. ****ty? yes.)