Best Game Show Reaction EVER (I've Got a Secret, 2006)
Okay, so this is old, but it's worth the posting. In 2006, the Game Show Network did a new version of the classic game show, I've Got a Secret, where a group of celebrity panelists attempted to guess a contestant's secret by asking yes/no questions. One of the sort-of twists, though, was that in this new version all of the panelists (and maybe the host, though I'm not sure about that) were gay.
So anyway, check out the reaction panelist Jermaine Taylor had after he finds out that their secret guest was Martha Wash, of The Weather Girls and C+C Music Factory fame (at around the 3-minute mark):