Poll: Bigger Impact: Lady Gaga or Mariah Carey?

Ray Bass

When all is said and done, and their careers are OVER , in the USA, who will be seen as having made a greater impact?

Lady Gaga or Mariah Carey?

Who'll have had made a bigger impact once both stop releasing music, not who has made a bigger impact until now.

Discuss.

xAyana

Mariah.

Retro

Will I be crucified for saying that I think it will be Gaga if she remains successful?

Jabril

Gaga

EOMM92

Gaga, Mariah isn't much more than just a vocalist..

Starburst

Oh, I clicked the poll option before reading the OP.

Still, Gaga has quite a ways to go to match Mariah's impact. I mean, All I Want For Christmas alone is one of the most iconic Christmas songs of all time.

SaneBeyhannaStan

This is Random but Mariah.

Honey

Mariah.

Harajuku

Depends on how ARTPOP goes. for now i'll say Mariah

rihannabiggestfan

Mariah 99%

Hollister

right now Mariah..

B2R4D

Lady Gaga to be honest.

What is the most iconic thing Mariah has done? The Christmas song? Even though Madonna and Michael came before her, I am still more aware of their hits. Mariah's music isn't even that remembered.

Pop pop123

What's this mess?

Mariah's legacy spans across generations of singers.

atrlster

Gaga has basically passed most of the pop divas at this point. The only ones who may challenge her are Madonna and Britney Spears

Ray Bass

Quote:

Originally posted by EOMM92

Gaga, Mariah isn't much more than just a vocalist..

I kinda agree. Gaga has many ways of surpassing Mariah's success.

HausOfGerard

Quote:

Originally posted by B2R4D

Lady Gaga to be honest.

What is the most iconic thing Mariah has done? The Christmas song. Even though Madonna and Michael came before them, I am still more aware of their hits. Mariah isn't even that remembered.

This

i spit on haters

Mariah.

GlitterfiedCyrus

Gaga, but not by much

BadKidBrodie

Gaga.

Remixed

Gaga.

Mariah hasn't made a lot of impact