I'll do this


But really, how did 4 of the most powerful women in music (and Celine) have such a middling selection of #1s?

oh yes!

all of whitney + celine to get punched out first

I haven't listened to half of them so I can't do this

Nope! I will drag.

Ohh, this is gonna be good. I'll do up my scores when I sit down tonight.

You've got over two weeks! You can do it

This is actually a fun game! Let's do the IDEAL version of how we wished their number ones had played out, using the same number of number ones they earned (11/18/4/10/12) [they had to have been singles, though!]:

Ideal

Whitney
You Give Good Love
Saving All My Love for You
All at Once
I Wanna Dance with Somebody
So Emotional
Love Will Save the Day
I'm Your Baby Tonight
Run to You
It's Not Right, But It's OK
My Love is Your Love
Million Dollar Bill

Mariah
Vision of Love
Emotions
Can't Let Go
Make It Happen
I'll Be There
If It's Over
Dreamlover
Anytime You Need a Friend
All I Want for Christmas is You
Always Be My Baby
Underneath the Stars
Butterfly
The Rook
Breakdown
Heartbreaker
We Belong Together
I'll Be Lovin U Long Time
#Beautiful

Celine
Where Does My Heart Beat Now?
The Power of Love
Think Twice
It's All Coming Back to Me Now

Janet
When I Think of You
The Pleasure Principle
Miss You Much
Rhythm Nation
Escapade
Come Back to Me
Love Will Never Do (Without You)
The Best Things in Life are Free
Because of Love
Someone to Call My Lover

Madonna
Burning Up
Like a Virgin
Borderline
Angel/Into the Groove
Papa Don't Preach
Open Your Heart
Like a Prayer
Express Yourself
Vogue
Get Together

Madonna and Janet were the hardest tbh, they should both have at least fifteen number one singles.

This is when my age comes out.

Mariah should dominate, but Live to Tell should win

I'll definitely be doing this.

I am ALL over this.

Will be dragging Celine.
I'll be nice to Whitney, but won't give her TEW much.
Madonna's will either get great scores or mediocre scores.
Same with Mariah.
Janet's will all be getting their rightful praise.

madonna will get great scores...at least from me..

This definitely has my votes