Poll: #1 Album:Rihanna vs Christina

aaronsmithjune1

Who's album will go number #1 if released in the same week?

Weemanply109

Obviously Christina.

CaptainMusic

Neither.

Rihanna will sell more than Xtina but Taylor will probably end up blocking both.

This thread will be a mess though.

werewolf

Christina. I think her record will be on point this time around.

Prince Andres

Even if 7 is a lucky number, Rihanna's 7th studio album still won't bring her a #1 album, especially if it's released this year.

UnusualBoy

Well Xtina's Bionic sold 110/130k first week with a flop first single if YB success she could do that or even more so I think I go with her. I lost hope with Rihanna after not getting 200k even when such a monster hit as WFL was.

paulyyyozd

Christina

aaronsmithjune1

I think Christina to...

Great Username

Neither, but Christina's would chart higher!

EdgeOfAddiction

Rihanna. But regardless, top 3 debut is guaranteed for this queen.

Squall

None but I go with Rihanna.

Euphoria

Christina will definitely chart higher. Rihanna can sells singles like crazy but she can't sell albums. Taylor's Red is scaring me though. Hopefully Lotus is released towards the end of November so sales for Red will have started to die down by then.

Glassheart

both will be murdered by Taylor

Shelter

Xtina. Rihanna couldn't even hit 200k with the monster We Found Love.

debutante

Idk but I feel like Xtina's is gonna be a bit of a damp squib.. again... not impressed by anything so far.

EdgeOfAddiction

Quote:

Originally posted by Euphoria

Christina will definitely chart higher. Rihanna can sells singles like crazy but she can't sell albums. Taylor's Red is scaring me though. Hopefully Lotus is released towards the end of November so sales for Red will have started to die down by then.

In this day and age, Rihanna is guaranteed a top 3 debut and if she were to go up against just Christina, Rihanna will come out victorious.

Quote:

Originally posted by Shelter

Xtina. Rihanna couldn't even hit 200k with the monster We Found Love.

WFL didn't gain traction till AFTER the release of the album. WFL in it's 5th week of release. It was a slow burner. Thanks for playing.

liberalmusiclover

Rihanna, easily.

PopNStuff

Christina hasn't released in November before, so it will be interesting to see if she can capture those holiday sales Rihanna hasn't been able to do. I'm hoping she will shock everyone and pull some B2B numbers.

Brite Lites ☆

Christina.

Desert Rain

I'm waiting to hear Ri's single before I make a full judgement.
Based on her past opening weeks though, I'm leaning towards XTina.