Discussion: The AHS Hotel Characters Rate - WINNER: Liz Taylor!!!

P!nk Forever

Welcome to the American Horror Story: Hotel Rate!

I'm so excited! I've hosted one before and it was quite larger than this but this shouldn't be a problem. But it was also so much fun to finally get the end results. The outcome was unexpected.

I hope you all watched this season steadily now that it has finished so that you can do the rate as soon as possible. I can't wait to receive your PMs.

There are 40 characters (which must all be considered) to give points to and additional ones (these are optional, can either be left out blank or not or you choose a few out of the bunch).

Now that this is clear let's move on to the most important part:

THE RULES:

1. Give each character a score from 1 to 10; Decimals are allowed (but only scores like 1.1, 8.4, 5.3, etc... and not 9.43422 for example; Scores of 0 will be rounded up to 1.[/FONT]

Please consider the following aspects in your methodology aka ranking system:

Acting
Writing (the characters story arc)
Appearance
Sympathy
Importance

2. Double check your ballots just in case you leave a score blank. Blank scores will be an automatic 1.

3. Send your rates to me via private message.

4. PLEASE use the PM friendly list near the end of this post!

5. Rates will be due February 3rd, 2016 at 0:00PM. The date may be extended if I don't get enough ballots which shouldn't be the case.

6. Obvious trolling scores will be disregarded.

7. If you want you can comment on each character why you chose that score and how much or how less you liked them.

THE CHARACTERS

MAIN:

Characters 1-10

1. John Lowe
2. Alex Lowe
3. The Countess
4. Liz Taylor
5. Iris
6. Donovan
7. Sally
8. James March
9. Ramona Royale
10. Will Drake

Characters 11-20

11. Tristan Duffy
12. Ms. Evers
13. Scarlet Lowe
14. Holden Lowe
15. Lachlan Drake
16. The Addiction Demon
17. Andy Hahn
18. Agnetha
19. Vendela
20. Gabriel

Characters 21-30

21. Claudia Bankson
22. Mrs. Ellison
23. Max Ellison
24. Madeline
25. Jimmy
26. Aileen Wuornos
27. Jeffrey Dahmer
28. John Wayne Gacy
29. Richard Ramirez
30. Hipster Justin

Characters 31-40

31. Hipster Babe
32. Mr. Wu
33. Wren
34. Valentino
35. Natacha
36. Douglas Pryor

SEASONAL:

Consider the backstory of these characters and include it with their presence in 'Hotel'.

37. Marcy (Murder House)
38. Charles Montgomery (Murder House)
39. Queenie (Coven)
40. Billie Dean Howard (Murder House)
_____________________________________
OPTIONAL:

You are given the choice to give the following options a rating. You may NOT rate these higher than a 5! It's up to you if you rate them all or take some out. Characters not listed can also be considered if of importance.

*Bobby (Vamp kid)
*Walter (Vamp kid)
*Lumberjack (Grindr Guy)
*Prophet Moses (Ramona's former lover)
*Gordon Northcott
*Zodiac Killer
*Craig (Devil's Night victim)
*Bartholomew
*Cara (Elementary School Teacher)
*Gibby (Elizabeth's friend)
*F.W. Murnau (Director of Dracula)
*Martin Gamboa (10 Commandment Victim)
*Stormcock (**** Director)
*Mary Magdalen (**** Actress)
*Lex (**** Actor)
*Mr. Royale
*Nick Harley (Grunge Musician)
*Tina Black (Grunge Musician)
*Mitch (Travel blogger)
*Jo (Travel blogger)

PM FRIENDLY LIST

THE SCHEDULE

THE PARTICIPANTS

THE RESULTS

P!nk Forever

Thread is open now!

You can send me your rates from now on!

Stark

Sent!

Brunette Ambition

Sent.

But you added too many useless characters, again. Jimmy or Maddie shouldn't be have to rated, they had like 2 lines.

Girlicious

I might not rate the optional ones because idrc

Also I hope you're allowing comments, cause I have a lot to say

P!nk Forever

Quote:

Originally posted by Brunette Ambition

Sent.

But you added too many useless characters, again. Jimmy or Maddie shouldn't be have to rated, they had like 2 lines.

Well then you rate them a 1 or so. A rate with only 10 characters would be boring. Also it wouldn't work out quite well.The more, the merrier.

P!nk Forever

Quote:

Originally posted by Girlicious

I might not rate the optional ones because idrc

Also I hope you're allowing comments, cause I have a lot to say

Sure. Spill it, sis! Drag me left to right.

P!nk Forever

4 in, so far!

I just checked all the PMs and Girlicious, I think it's a great idea that you commented on every character. Deffo gonna include your comments once the results are out. I'm gonna do the same. Also, added it to the rules.

Nutitle

Holden and Scarlett FTW

C/H/A/N/E/L

Sent my rates in.

I actually rated each of the 5 aspects (Writing, acting, appearance, sympathy & importance) out of 10, found the average, & used the average for my ranking of each character.

Didn't have a single 10 average, nor a 1.

Almodusa

Quote:

Originally posted by C/H/A/N/E/L

Sent my rates in.

I actually rated each of the 5 aspects (Writing, acting, appearance, sympathy & importance) out of 10, found the average, & used the average for my ranking of each character.

Didn't have a single 10 average, nor a 1.

Wow!

---
I'll be doing this soon

Nutitle

Sent! I guess

C/H/A/N/E/L

n wait

P!nk, lemme resubmit with my comments as well.

P!nk Forever

Quote:

Originally posted by C/H/A/N/E/L

n wait

P!nk, lemme resubmit with my comments as well.

Yay, can't wait! #Essays4TheWin

zoldyck

Velvet

Let me get started

Edit: Sent

2014

Sign me up for this

Noah

Just sent mine

P!nk Forever

Damn! C/H/A/N/E/L O/B/E/R/L/I/N really killed IT with ha comments. Some people are going to fume!

11 people have sent me their rates so far. Keep going!

P!nk Forever

to this rate and how well it has started. I hope for many more submissions!