The title says it all, before you were aware of the charts, which songs would you have SWORN went #1. Post your top 5 songs that felt so HUGE that you thought went #1.

1. One Republic- Apologize, I was so surprised to see this was never a #1 hit, it was literally inescapable back in the day lol

2. Nicki Minaj- Starships, it peaked at FIVE!?!?!? was sooo confused, like, what 4 songs could've possibly been bigger, because this song REIGNED

3. Nicki Minaj- Superbass, the radio play, the music video, just everything, it was sooo massive

4. Cee lo Green- Forget you, lets not act like it wasn't as big or bigger than BTW lol

5. Taylor Swift- You Belong with me, just

Those 5 songs are ones I was absolutely convinced had gone #1, honorable mention to Gangnam Style, Ellie Goulding Lights and Beyonce Halo, and i'm still dumbfounded as to why same love never went top10 it felt like a top 5 atleast

Your turn

Oops!, Toxic
Party In the USA

Halo wasnt #1? omfg....
The Edge of Glory is #1 material

**** you by Celo didnt hit #1? Waaaaaaaat
---

But Bad Romance poor sis

Party In The USA and We Can't Stop were both blocked at #2

So many Britney songs tbh

Bad Romance
Don't Stop The Music

Nope .. Peaked at 2 I think

Since U Been Gone

Stay and DSTM.

Lights too

Complicated - Avril Lavigne

Slayships & Super Godss

I forgot PITUSA, the fact that wasnt #1, but it was blocked by IGAF I think so, thats understandable I guess

Stay by Rihanna definitely seemed like it was a #1 single, but it peaked at #3.

Problem
Fancy

I always assumed Dirrty was a big hit or something till I joined ATRL and found out otherwise

Britney Spears: OIDIA, Toxic, Gimme More

Hunter Hayes: Wanted

Justin Timberlake: Mirrors, Cry Me a River

I think Starships should ne my #1, like im still shocked it peaked at 5

Adorn by Miguel lol & Pon De Replay