I didn't even care much for the first two Spider-Man movies, they were cute and all tho. I actually loved the third one, though it's a very unpopular opinion, but I don't know.
Maybe it's because I saw it in theaters and it was an amazing experience.
The Amazing Spider-Man was really great, probably even better than SM3, so my favorite of them all. The sequel looks very promising so I'm sure I'll love that as well.
I think Andrew is more suited for the character, as well.