Round 3 is here!
Consider vocals, dancing, writing, producing, musicanship, performing directing etc. etc. and form an opinion.
Vote in the poll!

Also vote in the first round:
Katy vs Ke$ha
http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=119847

and the second:
Britney vs Rihanna
http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=119919

The performer of our generation and one of the best if not the best singer of the 21st century, Beyonce.

• Vocals: Beyonce
• Dancing: Beyonce
• Writing: Lady Gaga
• Producing: Lady Gaga
• Musican ship: Lady Gaga
• Performing: Beyonce
• Directing: Lady Gaga

2 of the most talented pop stars right now, but I choose Lady Gaga.

Definitely, Beyonce is more talented than Gaga.
Both are superstars, great performers, singers. Both are very talented.

Looking at those criteria Beyonce wins decisively. She's better dancer, singer, actress.

I'd give point in favour of Gaga in writing and stanship.

* Vocals: Beyonce - I just don't want to discuss about it here

* Dancing: Beyonce - Isn't it too obvious?

* Writing: Beyonce - Please no bull******** about writing credits

* Producing: Beyonce - Turning a supposedly Country song to a massive RnB hit, Irreplaceable.

* Musican ship: Beyonce - The legend of crossover genres.

* Performing: Beyonce - Oh oh oh...

* Directing: Beyonce - I AM... TOUR. Your fave could never.

I'd argue with Musicanship but rest seems to be true.
I'm definitely choosing Beyonce, that's not even a question.

Beyonce

She's the better singer, dancer, performer and artist.

This is a fair comparison.

Beyonce produces better than Gaga, and not just on her own music. Gaga doesn't even produce her songs, Redone and etc... do!

Lady GaGa

Gaga has the main production credit on Born This Way, and co-produced every track on the album

OMG Lady Gaga is not really winning this poll at the moment.

Beyoncé is more talented, hands down.

Is the album even out yet. Tracklist? Official producer and writing credits?