Can we close this thread, mods?

Isn't there some interview of her claiming she wrote everything on B'Day by herself or something?

oh gurl, you are in trouble

she spends the majority of her time facing writing credit lawsuits.

and then there's this

I think what stirred it up the most was the Already Gone-Halo-Leona Lewis thing.

Halo was written for Leona Lewis, but then Beyonce got credited as a songwriter. Well, I don't know the whole facts or stories about such, but I started hearing "Sucha Thief" during that time.

Something having to do with a homosexual fish named Ne-Yo.

Just visit Irreplaceable's Wikipedia page and go to where it talks about Ne-yo's comments. That's essentially where it started. So yeah this thread is just Flamebait Central.

In before the lock

Has she ever been successfully sued for stealing lyrics?
No one would steal if they knew they could so easily be caught. The Countdown video is an obvious homage to the original.

If you're gonna shade, don't lie

I wonder how quickly this will be closed

and this thread is still open because?

I don't think she is generally considered a thief, but there are people claiming she is one because of those messy lawsuits.

What even is this