P!nk is ******** on everyone of those girls. She's bigger than all of them. She's one of the biggest stars worldwide now. She's achieved so much. I LOVE both Xtina and P!nk, but P!nk has had the better career.
Pink has never had the mega success of Christina's first two albums, but she's also never had the mega bump of Bionic either. I went with Pink, though I definitely wish it had been Christina. :-/
I am going with XTina based on general popularity, album sales, and awards garnered. Pink has definitely been more consistent, but continues to be underrated and less iconic than XTina.