I welcome you to the American Horror Story Rate! I was being told that this shall be a Lounge Rate, so here we are!

First of all: BEWARE OF ANY SPOILERS! Especially if you haven't gone through all 4 seasons! So WATCH and RATE right away!

4 seasons filled with suspicious, interesting and tremendous characters are waiting for your judgement. From Tate Langdon in Season 1 to Pepper in Seasons 2 and 4 to Fiona Goode in Season 3... no important character will be missed... not even the minor important ones.

I may have settled this up this weekend so we can start right away. The list of characters to be rated on includes approximately 140 which will also be revealed soon along with the rules.



If you have any questions I'll try to answer them in this thread.

Otherwise I hope to see you participate in this rate when it starts!


THE RULES:

1. Give each character a score from 1 to 10; Decimals are allowed (but only scores like 1.1, 8.4, 5.3, etc... and not 9.43422 for example; Scores of 0 will be rounded up to 1.[/FONT]
2. Double check your ballots just in case you leave a score blank. Blank scores will be an automatic 1.
3. Send your rates to me via private message.
4. PLEASE use the PM friendly list near the end of this post!
5. Rates will be due February 28th, 2015 at 0:00PM. The date may be extended if I don't get enough ballots which shouldn't be the case.
6. Obvious trolling scores will be disregarded.

ATTENTION!!! SPOILERS!!! ATTENTION!!! SPOILERS!!! ATTENTION!!! SPOILERS!!!


I've put some spoilers in there if you can't recall some of the characters. For further research visit The American Horror Story Wiki which may give you more detailed explanations. You could also sit through all 4 seasons again and by watching the series rate the specific characters. Some even more (minor) characters may be missing in this rate which I'm aware of - they should not be much of importance.

THE LIST:

MURDER HOUSE
1. Vivien Harmon Played by: Connie Britton; main cast; Death: Hemorrhage after giving birth
2. Dr. Ben Harmon Played by: Dylan McDermott; main cast; Death: Hanged by Fiona/Dallas/Hayden
3. Tate Langdon Played by: Evan Peters; main cast; Death: Shot by S.W.A.T. team
4. Violet Harmon Played by: Taissa Farmiga; main cast; Death: Suicide/Sleeping Pills
5. Larry Harvey Played by: Denis O'Hare; main cast; Burnt Man
6. Constance Langdon Played by: Jessica Lange; main cast; Neighbor of the Harmons
7. Hayden McClaine Played by: Kate Mara; Death: Shovel to the head by Larry
8. Chad Warwick Played by: Zachary Quinto; Death: Neck snapped by Tate
9. Moira O'Hara Played by: Frances Conroy (old) & Alexandra Breckenridge (Young); Death: Shot in the eye by Constance
10. Nora Montgomery Played by: Lily Rabe; Death: Suicide
11. Adelaide Langdon Played by: Jamie Brewer; Death: Hit by a car
12. Marcy Played by: Christine Estabrook; Real Estate Agent
13. Luke Played by: Morris Chestnut; Security Officer
14. Dr. Charles Montgomery Played by: Matt Ross; Death: Shot in the head by Nora
15. Troy & Bryan Played by: Kai & Bodhi Schulz; Death: Killed by Infantata
16. Travis Wanderly Played by: Michael Graziadei; Death: Stabbed by Hayden
17. Dr. Hall Played by: Eva Gordon; Vivien's Gynecologist
18. Patrick Played by: Teddy Sears; Death: Beaten and sodomized by Tate
19. Billie Dean Howard Played by: Sarah Paulson; Psychic Medium
20. Leah Played by: Shelby Young; Violet's frienemy
21. Lorraine Harvey Played by: Rebeccy Wisocky; Death: Suicide, burned alive
22. Beauregard Langdon Played by: Sam Kinsey; Death: Smothered with a pillow by Larry
23. Elizabeth Short Played by: Mena Suvari; Death: Accidental overdose of nitrous oxide; known as Black Dahlia
24. Infantata Played by: Benjamin Woolf; Real Name: Thaddeus Montgomery; Son of Nora & Charles
25. Hugo Langdon Played by: Eric Close; Death: Shot 3 times in the chest by Constance
26. Jack Colquitt¹ Played by: Geoffrey Rivas; Detective
27. Granger Played by: Charles S. Dutton; Detective
28. Barrios Played by: Malaya Rivera Drew; Female Detective (Granger's partner)
29. R. Franklin Played by: Jamie Harris; Serial Killer who murdered Maria and Gladys
30. Joe Escandarian Played by: Amir Arison; Death: Smothered with a plastic bag
31. Derrick Played by: Eric Stonestreet; Death: Shot during a home burglary; Ben's patient
32. Kyle Greenwell Played by: Brando Eaton; Death: Shot by Kyle; Westfield High 1993 victim
33. Chloe Stapleton Played by: Ashley Rickards; Death: Shot by Kyle; Westfield High 1993 victim
34. Stephanie Boggs Played by: Alessandra Torresani; Death: Shot by Kyle; Westfield High 1993 victim
35. Kevin Gedman Played by: Jordan David; Death: Shot by Kyle; Westfield High 1993 victim
36. Amir Stanley Played by: Alexander Nimetz; Death: Shot by Kyle; Westfield High 1993 victim
37. Gladys Played by: Celia Finkelstein; Death: Drowned by R. Franklin; Nurse
38. Maria Played by: Rosa Salazar; Death: Stabbed by R. Franklin; Nurse
39. Bianca Forest Played by: Mageina Tovah; Death: Stabbed with an axe; Ben's patient/R. Franklin re-enactor
40. Fiona Played by: Azura Skye; Death: Drowned, throat slit; R. Franklin re-enactor
41. Dallas Played by: Kyle Davis; Death: Throat slit; R. Franklin re-enactor
42. Stan Played by: David Anthony Higgins; Tour Guide leading through the Murder House
43. Miguel Ramos Played by: Anthony Ruivivar; New house owner
44. Stacey Ramos Played by: Lisa Vidal; New house owner
45. Gabriel Ramos Played by: Brennan Mejia; Son of Miguel & Stacey

ASYLUM
1. Dr. Oliver Thredson Played by: Zachary Quinto; main cast; Death: Shot by Lana
2. Monsignor Timothy Howard Played by: Joseph Fiennes; main cast; Death: Suicide
3. Lana Winters Played by: Sarah Paulson; main cast; Journalist/Book Author
4. Kit Walker Played by: Evan Peters; main cast; Gas Station Attendant
5. Grace Bertrand Played by: Lizzie Brocheré; main cast; Death: Murdered with an axe by Alma
6. Dr. Arthur Arden Played by: James Cromwell/John Cromwell (young); main cast; Death: Suicide by cremation
7. Sister Jude Martin Played by: Jessica Lange; main cast; Death: Unknown sickness
8. Sister Mary Eunice McKee Played by: Lily Rabe; Death: Thrown from stairway by Timothy; also in Season 4
9. Shelley Played by: Chloe Sevigny; Death: Strangled by Timothy
10. Leigh Emerson Played by: Ian McShane; Mass Murderer/False Santa Claus
11. Pepper Played by: Naomi Grossman; Briarcliff Inmate (Season 2)/Freak Show Performer (Season 4)
12. Wendy Peyser Played by: Clea DuVall; Death: Murdered by Oliver
13. Alma Walker Played by: Britne Oldford; Death: Unknown illness
14. Teresa Morrison Played by: Jenna Dewan Tatum; Death: Skinned by Johnny
15. Johnny Morgan Played by: Dylan McDermott; Death: Shot by Lana; Son of Lana & Oliver
16. Shachath Played by: Frances Conroy; The Angel of Death
17. Leo Morrison Played by: Adam Levine; Death: Shot by Bloody Face Imitator
18. Mother Claudia Played by: Barbara Tarbuck; Mother Superior
19. Spivey Played by: Mark Consuelos; Death: Shot by Arthur
20. Charlotte Brown Played by: Franka Potente; believes she is Anne Frank
21. Frank McCann Played by: Fredric Lehne; Death: Throat slashed by Mary Eunice; Head of Security
22. Carl Played by: Mark Engelhardt; Gets sexual pleasure from Shelley
23. Sam Goodman Played by: Mark Margolis; Death: Killed by Mary Eunice; Nazi hunter/Detective
24. Missy Stone Played by: Kristin Slaysman/Chelsea Valentine (young); Girl who got hit by Judy's car; Nurse
25. Billy Played by: Joe Egender; Harasses Kit for having a relationship with a black woman
26. Jed Potter Played by: Devon Graye; Death: Heart attack; Boy who was possessed by the devil
27. Mexican Played by: Gloria Laino; Death: Stabbed by Mary Eunice; Briarcliff Inmate
28. Dr. Miranda Crump Played by: Robin Bartlett; New head at Briarcliff
29. Jenny Reynolds Played by: Nikki Hahn; Little girl who has killed her entire family
30. Jim Brown Played by: David Chisum; Charlotte's Husband

COVEN
1. Cordelia Foxx Played by: Sarah Paulson; main cast; Daughter of Fiona
2. Zoe Benson Played by: Taissa Farmiga; main cast; Council member
3. Myrtle Snow Played by: Frances Conroy; main cast; Death: Burned at the stake by Fiona and again by Cordelia
4. Kyle Spencer Played by: Evan Peters; main cast; Butler (formerly Frat Boy)
5. Misty Day Played by: Lily Rabe; main cast; Death: Inability to ascend from hell
6. Madison Montgomery Played by: Emma Roberts; main cast; Death: Strangled by Kyle
7. Spalding Played by: Denis O'Hare; main cast; Death: Stabbed by Zoe; Butler
8. Delphine LaLaurie Played by: Kathy Bates; main cast; Death: Sent to hell by stabbing in the neck of Queenie
9. Fiona Goode Played by: Jessica Lange; main cast; Former Supreme Witch
10. Marie Laveau Played by: Angela Bassett; Death: Dismembered by Delphine; Voodoo Queen
11. Queenie Played by: Gabourey Sidibe; Council member; Living Voodoo Doll
12. The Axeman Played by: Danny Huston; Death: Stabbed by 1919/newer Coven; Fiona's lover
13. Joan Ramsey Played by: Patti LuPone; Death: Forced to drink bleach by Nan
14. Stevie Nicks Played by: Herself; Musician/Witch
15. Nan Played by: Jamie Brewer; Death: Drowned by Fiona & Marie
16. Hank Foxx Played by: Josh Hamilton; Death: Queenie shooting herself in the head; Witch Hunter
17. Minotaur Played by: Ameer Baraka; Death: Decapitation by Fiona/Life taken by Papa Legby; aka Bastien
18. Luke Ramsey Played by: Alexander Dreymon; Death: Smothered with a pillow by Joan
19. Chantal Played by: Dana Gourrier; Death: Shot by Hank; Salon worker/Voodoo witch
20. Pauline LaLaurie Played by: Raeden Greer; Death: Hanged by Marie; Delphine's youngest daughter
21. Borquita Lopez Played by: Jennifer Lynn Warren; Death: Hanged by Marie; Delphine's daughter of 1st marriage
22. Marie Jeanne LaLaurie Played by: Ashlynn Ross; Death: Hanged by Marie; Delphine's 2nd eldest daughter
23. Louis LaLaurie Played by: Scott Michael Jefferson; Death: Hanged by Marie; Delphine's Husband
24. Papa Legba Played by: Lance Reddick; Spirit of the Dead (Voodoo)
25. Cecily Pembroke Played by: Robin Bartlett; Death: Dismembered by Myrtle; previous Council member
26. Harrison Renard Played by: Michael Cristofer; Death: Through the axe by Fiona; Witch Hunter; Hank's father
27. Quentin Fleming Played by: Leslie Jordan; Death: Dismembered by Myrtle; previous Council member
28. Kaylee Played by: Alexandra Breckenridge; Death: Headshot by Hank; Hank's affair
29. Anna-Lee Leighton Played by: Christine Ebersole; Death: Throat slashed by Fiona; Prior Superior
30. Alicia Spencer Played by: Mare Winningham; Death: Bludgeoned by Kyle; Kyle's mother
31. Dr. David Zhong Played by: Ian Anthony Dale; Death: Life force drained by Fiona
32. Brener Played by: Grey Damon; Death: Black Widow by Zoe; Madison's rapist
33. Millie Played by: Grace Gummer; Witch in the class of 1919; one of the Axeman's murderers

FREAK SHOW
1. Bette & Dot Tattler Played by: Sarah Paulson; main cast; Conjoined Twins/Freak Show Performers
2. Jimmy Darling Played by: Evan Peters; main cast; Freak Show Performer (Lobster Boy)
3. Dell Toledo Played by: Michael Chiklis; main cast; Death: Shot in the back of the head by Elsa; Strongman
4. Gloria Mott Played by: Frances Conroy; main cast; Death: Shot in the head by her son Dandy
5. Stanley Played by: Denis O'Hare; main cast; Con-Artist
6. Maggie Esmerelda Played by: Emma Roberts; main cast; Death: Sawed in half by Chester; Con-Artist/Fortune Teller
7. Dandy Mott Played by: Finn Wittrock; main cast; Death: Drowned in water tank; Mass Murderer
8. Desiree Dupree Played by: Angela Bassett; main cast; Freak Show Performer (3-breasted woman)
9. Ethel Darling Played by: Kathy Bates; main cast; Death: Knife thrown into the eye by Elsa; Bearded Woman
10. Elsa Mars Played by: Jessica Lange; main cast; Death: Stabbed by Edward; Freak Show Owner/Hollywood Actress
11. Lillian Hemmings Played by: Celia Weston; Death: Stabbed by Desiree; Museum Curator
12. Regina Ross Played by: Gabourey Sidibe; Death: Gunshot by Police Officer; Daughter of Dora
13. Edward Mordrake Played by: Wes Bentley; Collector of Souls (in afterlife)
14. Chester Creb Played by: Neil Patrick Harris; Salesman/Magician
15. Massimo Dolcefino Played by: Danny Huston; Prosthetist; Elsa's love interest
16. Andy Played by: Matt Bomer; Death: Dismembered by Dandy; Gay Prostitute/Artist
17. Amazon Eve Played by: Erika Ervin; Death: Shot by Dandy; Freak Show Performer (Tall/Strongwoman)
18. Paul the Illustrated Seal Played by: Mat Fraser; Death: Shot by Dandy; Freak Show Performer (The Illustrated Seal)
19. Ma Petite Played by: Jyoti Amge; Death: Crushed by Dell; Freak Show Performer/Elsa's personal assistant
20. Legless Suzi Played by: Rose Siggins; Death: Shot by Dandy; Freak Show Performer
21. Salty Played by: Christopher Neiman; Death: Stroke; Freak Show Performer/Pepper's Husband
22. Toulouse Played by: Drew Rin Varick; Death: Shot by Dandy; Freak Show Performer
23. Penny Played by: Grace Gummer; Death: Shot by Dandy; Freak Show Performer (Lizard Girl)
24. Corey Bachman Played by: Major Dodson; young boy (kid) who was being held captive by Twisty
25. Twisty Played by: John Carroll Lynch; Death: Stabbed by Edward; Clown/Mass Murderer
26. Bonnie Lipton Played by: Skyler Samuels; girl who was being held captive by Twisty
27. Dora Brown Played by: Patti LaBelle; Death: Throat slashed by Dandy; Maid
28. Jack Colquitt² Played by: P.J. Marshall; Detective
29. Ima Wiggles Played by: Chrissy Metz; Death: Shot by Dandy; Freak Show Performer; aka Barbara
30. Vince Played by: Lee Tergesen; Penny's father
31. Eudora Tattler Played by: Ann McKenzie; Death: Murdered by Bette & Dot (her daughters)
32. Dr. Myron Bonham Played by: Jerry Leggio; Ethel's doctor
33. Meep Played by: Benjamin Woolf; Death: Beaten by Inmates; Freak Show Performer
34. Angus T. Jefferson Played by: Malcolm Jamal-Warner; Desiree's lover
35. Marjorie Played by: Jamie Brewer; Death: Stabbed by Chester; Chester's Puppet
36. Alice Played by: Angela Sarafyan; Death: Bludgeoned with hammer by Marjorie; Lucy's girlfriend
37. Lucy Creb Played by: Shauna Rappold; Bludgeoned with hammer by Marjorie; Chester's wife/Alice's girlfriend
38. Rita Gayheart Played by: Mare Winningham; Pepper's sister
39. Larry Gayheart Played by: Matthew Glave; Rita's Husband

Constance, Sister Jude, Sister Mary Eunice, Dandy, Lana, Moira, Marie Laveau and Hayden better sleigh!

I'm so perched for this!

Ok, trynna do this.

Can't wait

Can't wait to give everything, after Season 2, zeros.

There you go: http://ahs-source.com/photos/index.php?cat=5

YASSS. I am here for this. Can you post a PM friendly list of all the characters? thnxoxo

wait ill do this!

agree with the pm friendly list

Excited

Yes, I'll take care of that once I'm finished with preparations!

Here for it

Miss Lana Banana better win.

It has started!

I was gonna do this but it has way too many people *minor characters* and Im into giving them all 1s
great idea though

im here

I understand your concern. Though there might be either some of these characters you sympathize with by finding their acting or appearance great in that role or totally hate them.