Discussion: So Very Special: An ATRL Radiohead Rate (Winner announced!)

madonnas

Welcome to the ATRL Radiohead Rate! Radiohead is quite possibly the most critically acclaimed act to come from the 1990s. Radiohead took the world by storm with their iconic hit, "Creep," yet managed to keep critics interested by constantly reinventing, revamping, and innovating their style throughout their entire 20 year career. I have selected a crop of singles, promotional singles, and songs important to their career to rate. All you have to do is send me a private message rating each of these songs from a scale of 0 to 10 (0 being horrible, 10 being great). Have your rates in by August 23rd. Have fun!

Click

So Far...

Reminders:

You must rate every single song. There are only 39, so it shouldn’t be too much of a difficult task.
Actually listen to all the songs, all the way through.
If needed, I can extend the deadline, but remind me beforehand that you might need enough time.

Kang.

Oooooooooooooh

Lemme try to do this

Jack. Bauer

I thought this was going to say "So Very Special: An ATRL Christmas".

But I never really liked Radiohead.

Great idea for a thread though.

jomarr

August 15 is a week away. Make it two weeks please. I really am not familiar with them but I downloaded their whole discography so I might need two weekends for it

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by jomarr

August 15 is a week away. Make it two weeks please. I really am not familiar with them but I downloaded their whole discography so I might need two weekends for it

It's 9 days away

And I will extend it if need be, so don't worry

Flashing Lights

Ok, I'll do it madonnas.

Jameson Teqkilla

I am MAD that Weird Fishes is not on here.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by Jameson Teqkilla

I am MAD that Weird Fishes is not on here.

It's not a single! And it doesn't have notoriety like 15 Step/Idioteque do.

jomarr

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

It's 9 days away

And I will extend it if need be, so don't worry

Thanks. I'll start listening on Saturday. I really can't do it on a week day since I have work

Evun

I'm ready for No Surprises to win.

But actually Creep probably will.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by Evun

I'm ready for No Surprises to win.

But actually Creep probably will.

I will be FUMING and write condescending writeups if Karma Police and Creep are top 2. WATCH OUT!

Jabril

I've been trying to get into Radiohead so this is perfect for me. I just didn't know where to start.

What's their first album?

Kang.

Wasn't Everything in Its Right Place a single?

It AT LEAST has more notoriety than something like Idioteque, no?

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by Muggwa

Wasn't Everything in Its Right Place a single?

It AT LEAST has more notoriety than something like Idioteque, no?

Idioteque is a much more defining moment in their career than Everything in It's Right Place.

I couldn't put EVERY song from Kid A on it.

Evun

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

I will be FUMING and write condescending writeups if Karma Police and Creep are top 2. WATCH OUT!

Start writing, those are easily their two most (undeservingly) fangirl'd songs.

Changes

I could never get into Radiohead. Lemme give them another try with this rate.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by Evun

Start writing, those are easily their two most (undeservingly) fangirl'd songs.

Well, you should participate then and prevent that.

Jameson Teqkilla

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

Idioteque is a much more defining moment in their career than Everything in It's Right Place.

I couldn't put EVERY song from Kid A on it.

But they play it at almost every show.

Evun

Quote:

Originally posted by madonnas

Well, you should participate then and prevent that.

I will.

My first rate participation.

madonnas

Quote:

Originally posted by Jameson Teqkilla

But they play it at almost every show.

Sigh fine, I'll add it since it's the beginning right now (and cause I want more than 2 Kid A songs)