She doesn't have the vocal ability or the energy to pull the "Personal Jesus" sample to this level. Sad rip off.

http://youtube.com/watch?v=VFgf_jPGTow

Pointless thread. You basically just said that "Reach Out" sampled "Personal Jesus" and so did "Beware of the Dog". You also said Hilary can't pull it off vocally. Well, "Reach Out" is not an exact copy of "Personal Jesus".

Here's a live version of "Reach Out".

I'm 100% sure that Hilary Duff single "Reach Out" will be MUCH METTER, AND MORE HUGE, than she. Who is she? I never heard about her.
I like more the version of Hilary because is more sexy, and hilary's voice is very sweet

Sorry, MUCH BETTER, no much metter. Sorry for my sad english

The beat is identical to "Personal Jesus" and her vocals are shiteous. If she can't bring something as hot as Jamelia's version then what's the point of this being a lead single?!

Mazen always wants to pick on teenage singers because Madonna's album is a big bust!

Leave Hilary alone please

Hilary's is hotter than Jamelia's. Also, it's cool that all the Disney Queens get a thousand threads over a short time. It seems like Hilary, Miley, and Raven had all had countless amounts of threads in the past months.

Whatever if it's a rip-off or not. The song sucks either way.

We all have different music tastes.

WTH

Jamelia's >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> Hilary's

Who the **** is jamelia??????
and I don't like this song
REACH OUT will be a success!
and HARD CANDY

Hilary's monotone lifeless bland voice is the definition of HOT, according to her stans.

BOW TO THEM!!!!!!!!!!!1

But seriously, Hilary can't pull this song of, you need attitude for something like this, of which Hilary doesn't have unfortunately

Exactly. She needs to pick a shoe that fits her. Something as mediocre as "With luv luv luv luv ", no need to ruin such timeless samples this way.

I guess Madonna's monotone, lifeless, and bland voice is the definition of hot to you as well?

Sometimes you pepole kill me..How about waiting for the official song to come out and than judge, or bash or w/e you want to do..This is just pointless, the live version can be really diff from the official one.

again

It's pretty stupid to judge a song based on a low quality fan recording.

If that's the description of Madonna's voice then Hilary has an octave of a zombie.

LMAO, Madonna sounds like Whitney Houston in the early 90's if you compare her to Hilary.