One of the G.U.Y. haters' main complaints that I see is that the story got muddled within the video and it got confusing. Personally, I think it's a pretty clear and simple story and I understood it within my first viewing. She started as a broken star, milked by her label, and then left to suffer. She picked herself up and found her way to the Hearst Castle where she was reborn with help from the goddesses (The Real Housewives). She then extracted the greatness from the men she revived and exacted her revenge on the label executives by injecting them with it, turning them into kind men who were back on her side.
Simple, cute, and true. Does it really take that much thinking power to come up with it? Or do people just like to formulate reasons to hate on her?