Which pop superstar is a better songwriter ?

I've heard barely any solo-written Gaga songs so it is impossible to directly compare.

Taylor, undoubtedly.


The fact that this thread is made half a dozen times per year

Poll added

Taylor.

Gaga. The variety in her lyrics > Taylors repetitive love songs.

Lady Gaga wrote Just Dance, Poker Face, Bad Romance, and Dope, which are better than any Taylor songs, so she has my vote over Taylor.

Taylor.



Hm... I think you would be interest to check out the "Katy vs. Taylor" thread

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=398888

Again and again
Again, again, again, again
Never stop again and again
Again, again, a-a-again, again
Never stop, oh

This has already been made

Taylor won, but they both are great writers imo

Taylor
Gaga tries to hard to sound deep.

Gaga's lyrics are better.

Taylor

Taylor. Gaga is a talented songwriter, but her messy lyrics are just too much to be ignored. They are not just a few missteps, they are a lot.

Loving him was red re-e-e-ed-re-e-e-ed

The fact that they ended up with the same number of votes
Of course, since Gaga now has gained a lot more haters, the results of this poll will be very different.

Gaga. Taylor doesn't even try to write deeper or vulnerable lyrics. i like her music but her songs are incredibly vapid and shallow.

That's cute.

Lemme fix that for you.

Gaga. The variety in her lyrics which are pretentious and their concepts are not well-executed <<<<<<< Taylor's well-written, well-thought love songs.