Two of the most succesful pop stars right now. What do you think? Adding global superstar Rihanna to the song, would the song be more succesful, and would have hit #1. Discuss.

It would be Gaga's worst song.

Less. Rihanna was flopping in 09...

For I second I thought this was happening.






Anyway it would be more successful. No offense to Queen B but Rihanna would be better at playing a bad ass.

Less

less.

Idk. I think it wouldn't sound as good though.

omfg you had me running thinking she was on a re-make of telephone

-


not sure tbh

Given the more global appeal of Rihanna, it would have smashed harder.

I can definitely picture Gaga and Rihanna on a track together, but not that one (unless Bey's parts were way different). Probably would've done the same tbh.

Wasn't this released in 2010. Wasn't Rihanna spending 5 weeks with Rude Boy at hot 100 top?

More, off course.

More Successful, and would've made the song better.

I mean you would think.. Rude Boy blocked Telephone. So imagine if Rih was actually in the original song.. smash every where tbh

The irony since it was Rude Boy that blocked Telephone from the #1 spot. Girl

More.

And better.

Is that why Rude Boy was sitting comfortably at #1 during Telephone's peak?