you know...the ones that even if they record the biggest crap in the world, or they are untalented or nothing special, most of the members will always defend him/her/them until they die

my list

1. rihanna (c'mon...she just released "umbrella" and now everybody is her fan?)
2. avril lavigne (she is acting the way she used to criticized)
3. aly and aj (no...they will never debut on trl )

this is for "the lounge" ray

Nelly Furtado.

1. Umbrella is her 7th single of 9 now, i love her since S.O.S. (best song of 2006)
2. I agree that she's overrated, but not so much
3. Last year everyone was against them, maybe now they have proved how good they are, but there still everyone's against them...

I think there aren't overrated artists on ATRL, instead thete are a few of underrated artists...

That's exactly what I've been saying the whole time!

Kelly Clarkson too

You're an idiot! Rihanna is neither Overrated nor Underrated....and come on, Aly & A.J. overrated? There isn't enough people in the world (let alone ATRL) talking about them and you mean to tell me Justin or Christina isn't overrated? You are weird my friend....

Here's mine, and I'll go 5.

1. Christina Aguilera
2. Justin Timberlake (I'm not even gonna say it)
3. Lil Mama (no comment)
4. Avril Lavigne (I'll agree with you on her. Girlfriend is an annoying song IMO)
5. Timbaland (I have nothing against him at all....it's just his last 2 singles aren't what I exactly call a masterpiece )

I will not put Sean Kingston or any other rapper on this list because their singles are just warming up a bit on the charts and they haven't really had much of a run yet.......kinda makes me sick though that I'm saying this but I'm trying to be fair.

i won't comment pedro might get angry with me heheheh

and btw hilary duff lol

How could I forget T-Pain and Akon? OMG, goodness me

Mike, you're the idiot.

Aly & AJ are extremely overrated on ATRL in the sense that people talk about them SO MUCH, whether or not it's in a negative way.

Christina and Justin are overrated mostly due to the fact that you never shut the **** up about them.

I'd say Rihanna and Beyoncé.
No. Contest.

And for the record, I don't have anything against them, especially Rihanna, so get off my ass.

agree with the list!!! and no hilary duff is not overrated neither is kelly clarkson

Avril is now repulsive..

^ Yeah, Mike, but no one likes them here.

Hilary Duff and Aly & AJ for sure.

Britney, Shakira ()
Rihanna, Nelly Furtado, Hilary Duff, Xtina Justin. etc etc etc

Britney....

2006 ( she is working in a new album ) .............................2021 ( she is still working on it ).......

Britney, Rihanna, Hilary Duff, Fall Out Boy, Nickelback

I may like some songs but the above artists but they are very overrated here as artists...and everywhere.

Since most people don't like horrible rap artists like T-Pain, Mims, Shop Boyz, etc. here, they aren't really overrated here though they are very overrated by whoever requests this stuff on the radio and buys it on itunes.

1. Mims/Yung Berg/Hurricane Chris/Sean Kingston


and they are really underrated here lmao

1. Britney Spears, without a doubt.

If we're going by the criteria of the OP, I'm just gonna say Britney Spears and leave it at that. Not only are they crazy here, but did anyone see that thing on TV where somebody called Britney a ***** and a bunch of the girls straight-up jumped her? ****ing crazy bitches.

Yeah, Beyonce too.