Grammy Awards Check
Hits. Check.
Massive sales. Check.
Talent.Check.
Touring act. Check
Acclaim and awards check.
Iconic moments check
Great performances Check
Quality music Check

So she seems to have it all beside a few pressed people here and there who try to deny it.
Is she already a certified Icon?
Discuss Lady Gaga stans, admirers and haters around the world.

Between 2009-2011 alone she pretty much established herself as one of the most iconic pop acts of all time so this really isn't a question.

Whether or not she'll continue to see success remains a question, but anyone with any sense of objectivity can recognize that Gaga cemented a legacy for herself with her first 2 albums. It's not up for debate.

Poll is up. This technical glitches today are too much.
Vote wisely.

Yes.

Yes.

Let the Haters clearly hear this.

yes

certified Icon? Check

No. To be an icon you have to have atleast a 10 year old succesful career.

Lady Gaga started flopping five years into her career, and right now the GP doesnt care for ha or use ha anymore. Shes done. She basically our generations Cindy Lauper, two successful albums, then complete flop afterwards, struggling to stay relevant.

I thought Katy Perry wanted to have Cyndy's career if I am not wrong.
But back on the topic. I clearly disagree.

Yeah, she is kinda iconic. But we have to wait.

She did in 5 years more than what Xtina did in 10 years

Obviously

The Gaga that we knew during the TFM era was an icon. Now, not so much.

There's absolutely no rule that states this. I don't think you understand what "icon" means.

Tupac and Biggie Smalls are both hip-hop/music icons. Did they have 10 years of sustained mainstream success? I'll wait.

Yes.

Yes

Teaching people is always a humble act.

Definitely. She is the last megastar that we have. She can definitely re-bounce from Artpop