The Contenders:
- Alicia Keys "Superwoman"
- Brandy "Right Here (Departed)"
- Boys Like Girls "Thunder"
- Carrie Underwood "Just A Dream"
- Cassie f/ Lil' Wayne "Official Girl"
- Colbie Caillat "The Little Things"
- Coldplay "Viva La Vida"
- Danity Kane f/ Missy Elliott "Bad Girl"
- David Archuleta "Crush"
- Duffy "Warwick Avenue"
- Gym Class Heroes f/ The Dream "Cookie Jar"
- Jonas Brothers "Burnin' Up"
- Katy Perry "I Kissed A Girl"
- Keri Hilson "Energy"
- Lady Gaga "Just Dance"
- Leona Lewis "Forgive Me"
- Lifehouse "Broken"
- Mariah Carey f/ T.I. "I'll Be Lovin' U Long Time"
- Maroon 5 "Goodnight Goodnight"
- Miley Cyrus "7 Things"
- Natasha Bedingfield "Angel"
- Ne-Yo "Miss Independent"
- OneRepublic "Mercy"
- Robin Thicke "Magic"
- Taylor Swift "Love Story"
Voted Off:
- Pink "So What" (August 2008 Winner)
- Rihanna "Disturbia" (July 2008 Winner)
- Madonna "Give It 2 Me" (June 2008 Winner)
Vote Off 3, Save 2
Off:
- OneRepublic "Mercy"
- Danity Kane f/ Missy Elliott "Bad Girl"
- Jonas Brothers "Burnin' Up"
Save:
- Lady Gaga "Just Dance"
- Coldplay "Viva La Vida"