Hmmm well "Born This Way" the song was big but I think "Irreplaceable" and "Beautiful Liar" give Bey this one. So "B'Day".

Born This Way outside the US and B'Day in the US.

B'Day. Irreplaceable and Beautiful Liar alone destroy all BTW's singles combined.

Born This Way is the better album, but BDay is more remembered.

Born This Way's only remembered song is the title track, while the top 70 hit Listen from B'Day seems to be more known after almost 10 years.

B"Day the album is more iconic and remembered than BTW the album.
BTW the song is more remembered than Irreplaceable.

BTW

B'Day, easily.

Talking about quality, BDay easily wins - it's fantastic. In my trinity with self-titled and 4.

But no one can deny the power, impact and memorability of BTW era. Gaga was ruling the world back then. She achieved major commercial success with TF, enstablished herself as an icon during TFM, but during BTW it really seemed she was ruling the media world.

Btw imo but Listen and Irreplaceable are kind of iconic too

Born This Way
I think the song BTW is more remembered than Irreplaceable and the BTW era was a bigger event with all the shock values, performances, videos, costumes, etc

B'day trumps BTW. Irreplaceable is a classic that still gets radio play. Born This Way (title track) is completely forgotten and such a forced #1, had it be released anytime after Gaga's prime it wouldve done worse than Applause.

This!! I haven't heard any of BTW's singles in years, but I still hear Irreplaceable being played. And BTW is no where near as old as BDay.

B'Day

B'day definitely. Irreplaceable is still known and relevant while almost everything about the BTW era seems dated/forgotten.

Irreplaceable is a classic but as a whole, B'Day is Beyoncé's most forgotten album.

Born This Way is far more iconic and arguably remembered.

What is iconic about BTW? It's the era that turned people against Gaga.

BTW