Discussion: Etta James Cover: Beyoncé or Christina?

Quiqui4eva

Beyoncé at the Barack Obama Inaguration

Christina Aguilera at the Etta James Funeral

Who sang it better?

Bliss

Beyonce.

RichGirlPlanet

Beyoncé

Bad Wolf

Beyonce.

Christina just does too much with it. I'd probably say Christina's was better if she'd just sing the damn melody instead of trying to make the song one giant melisma.

Disturbia

Beyoncé. I dislike Christina's singing style, she just screams too much for my taste.

Doc

Beyoncé.
For reasons already clocked in this thread.

KingSasha

My 2 faves but obviously Beyoncé.

stop comparing them please and leave Xtina alone,this thread is just another way to talk about the ..****

Boop

Beyoncé

QueenBeyoncé

Beyoncé

Capital B

Xtina does too much.

I vote Bey.

alkralkra

Christina's was painful to watch.

Sorry.

DeathRevisited

Hers.

@TEAMFOXYDONDIVA

Christina I love you but to be honest I didnt even make it through the funeral performance.. Boring!!!! neway

Beyonce Toddlers Love on Top http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kn3vv...ature=youtu.be

Quiqui4eva

Quote:

Originally posted by KingSasha

My 2 faves but obviously Beyoncé.

stop comparing them please and leave Xtina alone,this thread is just another way to talk about the ..****

I didn't do this to shade Christina. I absolutely loved her version as well.

B94

Xtina.

@TEAMFOXYDONDIVA

Quote:

Originally posted by DeathRevisited

Hers.

Kisses baby! Beyonce is da baddest bad ting bout here!!!!! Beyonce Toddlers Love on Top http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kn3vv...ature=youtu.be

MrBeyonceFan

BEYONCE

JayRockafella

I ****ing love Beyonce but that one note christina hit like slayed me

JonnyϟLightning

Xtina.

Chunk

Quote:

Originally posted by J0rdan

Beyonce.

Christina just does too much with it. I'd probably say Christina's was better if she'd just sing the damn melody instead of trying to make the song one giant melisma.

here you go