I've seen various people citing her as one, so is she?

of course

No.

She was until her Femme Fatale era.

imo no. But she is a massive influence on Pop culture and is an icon.

why not?

This is what I think too

Yeah.

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=104474
+
http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=515126

Honestly, yes.

I think people voting no are saying so because they're comparing the Britney of recent years to her peers. And in that sense, you're right. She can't keep up with them. She can't dance as well as the ones who do dance, and she's literally the only girl who never, ever sings live. Not even once for a ballad every now and then. But the thing is, there was a point in time where she was the biggest celebrity on the planet, and the world went crazy for her. And if you're not old enough to remember it, that doesn't change the fact that it happened. And if you want to compare the Britney of 2014 to the other pop girls of 2014, that still doesn't change her legacy from the late 90s and early 2000s.

Her in her schoolgirl outfit from BOMT alone will be remembered decades from now. Just as people think of Elvis Presley's iconic looks and are reminded of the 60s, or think of Madonna/Michael Jackson's iconic looks and think of the 80s, they'll look at Britney's schoolgirl outfit and VMAs python look and will think of the late 90s/early 2000s. Regardless of how much talent she still has (or doesn't have) anymore, her legacy and her peak remain unbothered.

As 'Gimme More' says The Legendary Miss Britney Spears.

nothing showed up whe I searched for the thread

Yes people voting no are haters.

Yes. But she's not as big of a legend as the army says. There are things she's yet to do' but yes

Yes.

ducvjLQSXHnslcdjbclshfglbnkv WTF I screamedT so loud.

but OT she's more like a Pop Culture ICON tbh.

when I hear music Legend I think more about Whitney Houston, Mariah, Aretha, Stevie, Prince, Michael Jackson, Tina Turner, Beyoncé... people with actual memorable stage presence and talent.

as I used to say Madonna is an exception. and there'll never be another Madonna type of exception.

Yes (I missclicked and voted no )