She's still relevant, she's been in the game since '98. (15 years) She seemed to benefit from gradual success as opposed to a rapid rise followed by a steady decline. (ex. Gaga)

Christina's long been down for the count, Mariah had her dry spell, Whitney her dry spell, Britney's now bordering on it, Janet's been irrelevant since 2001...

Is Beyoncé the most consistent female since Madonna?

Rihanna, Katy Perry, Miley, etc. haven't been in the game long enough to judge.

Definitely one of.

Yes, I think so.

If not, definitely top5.

Yes, along with P!nk.

Madonna has never been consistent, if by that you mean always successful

Instead if by "consistent" you mean relevant or always in the GP minds so no, she's not.

One of, yes.

Not even close to it

What? Success and relevancy goes hand-in-hand. Both.

And she never suffered a true, certified flop until American Life. And by that point she was 20 years into her career.

And still sells more albums than your fave. What a flop.

[IMG][/IMG]

4 sold over a million copies.

P!nk says hi!

Yes.

@ people saying P!nk. She had her struggles with her debut and Try This. Beyonce never had a flop ever, and 4 is NOT a flop.

One of them

Her and P!nk definately are especially from their generation