Polly Jean Harvey, or
PJ Harvey, first exploded onto the scene in December 1991 with debut single "Dress". Since then, she has released eight solo albums and two collaborative albums, showcasing her in various different styles and incarnations, all the while retaining her ballsy and bold attitude.
Yet weirdly, there has
never been an ATRL rate to decide which of these singles is her best. Until now.
Twenty-five songs stand before you; only one can emerge as the winner.
THE RULES:
1. There is a total of
twenty-five songs in this rate. You must score
every song
from 0 to 10.
One lucky song can receive an
11 from you, if you so wish.
2.
PM your scores to
me. Don't post them in the thread!
3.
Decimals of up to 2 places are allowed. That means I will allow a 9.5, a 9.25, but
not a 9.733282819181614. So don't even try it.
4. The deadline is
midnight GMT on
November 15th, just over a month from now. I have included YouTube links in the OP, but there is also Spotify, Apple Music, etc., so no excuses!
5.
Commentaries are
appreciated, but
not compulsory. It's always nice to read why someone gave a 0 to a song, or why it got your 11, or why it got a 9 but not a 10.
6.
No trolling! If I so much as even suspect you're trying to rig the rate, I will refuse to count your scores.
7. Have fun!
PM-friendly list
Dress –
Sheela-Na-Gig –
50ft Queenie –
Man-Size –
Down By The Water –
C'mon Billy –
Send His Love To Me –
Henry Lee –
That Was My Veil –
Broken Homes –
A Perfect Day Elise –
The Wind –
Good Fortune –
A Place Called Home –
This Is Love –
You Said Something –
The Letter –
You Come Through –
Shame –
When Under Ether –
The Piano –
The Devil –
Black Hearted Love –
The Words That Maketh Murder –
The Glorious Land –
Spotify playlist courtesy of
Vulnicura!
