It's contrived, the lyrics are garbage, the melody is grating in several parts and it lacks the signature Christina vocal touch or any Christina element for that part. It's like she was imitating someone else.
But for whatever reason, everybody loves it and they get offended when I rightfully drag it through the mud
I can't pick one for Mariah, Prince, George or any of my top faves, so...
Poker Face. I've lowkey disliked it from the JUMP and never understood why it was more successful than Just Dance. Don't get me wrong I'll still bop to it occasionally but it was by no means better. Maybe it's me wanting #justice4justdance but.
I don't dislike it by anymeans and Thriller would definatly NOT be considered the GOAT album without it but I wouldn'f put it in my top 10 or even 20 MJ songs.
Also
Purple Rain for Prince
Flawless and Drunk In Love for Beyonce