The game is based in one of those mystery murder train games where a person is killed and no one knows who did it so detective has to investigate and interview everyone and then he decides who killed this person.

Basically the game is very similar but instead of a murder there will be different scenarios for each round where something happens and I interview everyone and then we guess who's guilty.

Wait, after reading it over a few times, this seems like fun Sign me up as a participant

Also, "Guess Who" seems like a better name, just thinking out loud

I'll do it

A few questions:
-If someone is immune do they have to take part in the next round?
-How long will immunity last for? I mean, a final with someone immune is unrealistic
-Is it one consistent character in several scenarios or a different character for each one?

- If someone is immune after the 1st round then they will be deciding who did it after the entries for that round are posted and the entries are anonymous so he will kick out the person with story that is less likely to be true and then give immunity to the story that he has no doubts that he didn't do it so they will not participate on the round they have immunity, they will be like a judge.
- Just for one round up to the 10th round.
- A different character for each scenario/round, one that fits the situation.

Ok

I changed it to "Guess Who Did It"

Sign me up.

1. boygagaloo
2. hello_world
3. Frankmusik

Ohhh this seems like fun, sign me up

1. boygagaloo
2. hello_world
3. Frankmusik
4. slayley
5. keshas pears xo

But wait. This might be the first game I've participated in. I'm a little nervous. I'm probably not going to be any good. You better be nice to me Gabe.

You shouldn't be nervous, I think its really easy so hopefully so you have fun I'll be nice

Sign me up.

1. boygagaloo
2. hello_world
3. Frankmusik
4. slayley
5. keshas pears xo
6. Nnmmo

I want to watch this game take place!!

What about being a guest star for a round?

How does that workkkk?

Its very simple. After the story entries are posted and everyone can read them including the "guests"
they will decide which stories they think are the most convincing and which are not. Just like the participants they will create their own character for said round and they will add more things to the stories by the participants which can either hurt them or help them.

Like if we go by the example in the OP.
Jane asks kid X about what was he doing when the present was stolen.
Kid Xsaid he was swimming in the pool
And then the "guest" can say something like "me and kid X where both in the swimming pool at the time the present was stolen" so by saying that the guest is helping kid X's story to become more believable because now you have several people saying the same story it is more likely to be true.
But if the "guest" says something like "kid X was not in the swimming pool I was there by myself" so by saying that the "guest" is hurting kid X's story which makes it more likely to be fake.

The guest can include several people in their story so it can help or hurt more than one people.
And in the end the "guest judge" will decide which story is most likely to be a lie and determine who stole present and that person will be eliminated.

*And I say kid X because as I said everyone will create their own character and their name so it will be anonymous.
*The guest will also create their own character it can be a kid at the party, an aunt, the husband, the brother, etc.

Yesssss let me do this!