How did I miss this thread?
Look, it is unanimously Taylor.

More than 200 votes for Taylor. Damn.

Taking the Long Way - Dixie Chicks


It's just above average country music...there were better choices that year.

I'm honestly shocked. I didn't even expect her to win when I made the thread.

Taylor Swift Fearless...seriously tho..that album won...like seriously?

I still don't understand what could possibly motivate these people to vote for OutKast:

REALLY? There isn't ONE winner you think is LESS deserving than the most critically acclaimed out of ALL of these albums?

I still want to know who deserved it over Fearless

Like, seriously pressed to be honest, like seriously.

Why "The Suburbs" didn't deserved it? Because Teenage Dream proved to be a better album.

do you know what unanimously means?

They are all brilliant, but I sadly like Herbie's album the least.

Yes. Wow, you really get nailed for a typo here.
I meant to say it is clearly Taylor. More than half voted for her.

Who seriously thinks 21 was not deserving?

Ah, so we can add "NON-KATY" to the question "Can anyone give me a NON-GAGA/NON-KATY reason as to why The Suburbs did not deserve to win Album of the Year?" Glad to clear that up.

What's funny is that The Suburbs' Metascore is approximately double was Teenage Dream's is.

So true.

The Fame!

It deserved to win out of the nominated albums....Groogrux King was not DMB's best work, I Am... had tons of filler, The Fame is a good pop album but many songs get old fast, The END was just pure trash. But out of albums released in the eligibility period, it was in no way close to the best released.