I'm such a flop pokemon stan. I didn't know there is a game like this.
Squirtle: 9.5
I love it in the series and I love how loyal it is.
In the game it's my second fave 1st gen starting fave pokemon and it's really useful in the first gym battle.
Charmander: 10
My fave. that "char char" is adorable..
Picking it as a starter though is tough since it's practically useless against the 1st 2 gyms but it's final evo *****..
It's the most challenging starter to us so I love it and use it often.
Bulbasaur: 9.0
My least fave out of the three 1st gen starting pokemon.
But I love it nevertheless. It's loyal to Ash's team and I love how it uses it's vines to rock togepi to sleep and help Ash when they're in trouble and saves them when they're falling or something. .
In the game the most useful against the first two gyms.
Caterpie: 6.9
Always rely to this during the start of the game. The first pokemon to always reach it's final evo on my team.
It's final evo ***** early in the game. Confusion at level 10.
But as a source of exp. in raising my pokemon it sucks.
I'm playing pokemon yellow for the nth time so these 4 pokemon are part of my team right now.
Scoring System
doesn't sound like a flop stan to me.
But they're cute gifts though. 
