P!nk - U + U R Hand/Who Knew
Janet Jackson - So Excited
Fergie - London Bridge( It did flopped massive here)
Kelis - Blindfold Me

And the albums
Kelis - Kelis Was Here
P!nk - I'm Not Dead
Janet Jackson - 20 Y.O.

Live in the Sky - T.I. f/ Jamie Foxx
Drive Slow - Kanye West f/ Paul Wall & T.I.
Pink - Who Knew
Eminem - When I'm Gone (I dunno if this one flopped)

Pink - Who Knew
Christina Milian - Say I
Ashlee Simpson - Invisible
Nelly Furtado - Maneater Just like everybody else, i thought it was gonna be HUGE...

Twista/MC - So Lonely(how/why did this flop again?)
Pink - Who Knew
Natasha B - Single
Cheyenne Kimball - Hanging On
Cascada - Miracle
Jeannie Ortega - Crowded

Pink - Who Knew?/U + Ur Hand
Cascada - Miracle
Teddy Geiger - These Walls
LeToya - She Don't
Fefe Dobson - This Is My Life
Saving Jane - Happy
Stefy - Chelsea
The Click Five - Catch Your Wave

Pink - Who Knew
Avenged Sevenfold - Seize The Day
The Black Eyed Peas - Pump It
The Pussycat Dolls - Buttons
Beyoncé - Check On It
Panic! At The Disco - I Write Sins Not Tragedies

how did that flop?

10 - 8 - OUT - 8 - 10

don't you agree? very bad chart run.
Buttons is a very awesome video, it deserved at least 30 days.

Who said we're talking about TRL? If we were talking about that, this topic would be in a different board now.

Who said we CAN'T talking about TRL?

Have you seen most songs that are posted here?

And besides, they flopped in TRL, but do you know how good they did in other video countdowns?

Yes. I often read the posts before replying.
I wanted to talk about TRL, but I know how much played Buttons was. Even here the video is having a great chart run. Btw not just Buttons, IWSNT and COI too.

Oh yeah... Those too. Meh, I don't really count TRL flops as true flops. Those 3 videos won in the VMA's and they have good Billboard runs, so yeah.

Some of the songs did pretty good on TRL, like Invisible, it was neck and neck with Ain't No Other Man for quite a while.

Yes, you're right.
So maybe the biggest flops are Who Knew and Get Together

hmm i might be wrong but ui wouldnt consider maneater a flop...its massive in my area

both were quite big outta US especially Who Knew went to Top10 in the following charts:

-United World Chart (9 weeks in Top10 peaking on #8, 2.8m points so far)
-Australian Aria Singles Chart (peak:2)
-Irish Singles Chart (peak:6)
-UK Singles Chart (peak:5)
-Czech Republic Singles Chart (peak:1)
-Portugal Airplay (peak:1)
-Polish Singles Chart (peak:5)
-Brazil Hit Parade Top 20 (peak:6)
-U.S. Billboard Euro Digital Tracks (peak:6)
*who knew is currently #4 on euro airplay char, u+ur hand is #6 and I'm Not Dead is #6 on albums chart

*One more thing: U+Ur Hand will be released in US on 31st October so it s early to call it a flop yet umm maybe not xD well at least it wasnt much of a flop on TRL, one of Pink's most succesful TRl runs