Originally posted by helloDer Amy's vocals **** on lives but Gaga's videos, production, and writing effortlessly top that

Perfectly said.

Originally posted by Deemy Singing and Writing. and Amy Winehouse plays instruments too I believe.

Gaga does all that too.

That's for you to break down and decide.



...Vin

Originally posted by iHooker Gaga does all that too.

Originally posted by sabertooth Its a close one. They're quite equal really. Amy just gets get the upper hand here because she's dead.

Originally posted by Vin That's for you to break down and decide. ...Vin

What does Vin think?

Originally posted by Deemy but one does it better.

Originally posted by Deemy Singing and Writing. and Amy Winehouse plays instruments too I believe.

Originally posted by BadBitch Yeah she plays the guitar but Gaga still wins.

Originally posted by sabertooth Its a close one. They're quite equal really. Amy just gets get the upper hand here because she's dead.

Vin, you love to discuss GaGa, don't you? When one of your threads close, another follows.


But anyways, i'm conflicted.

GaGa has songwriting, directing, production skill and a decent vocal ability.

While Amy has DAT VOICE and beautiful songwriting going for her.

...

I'll just say both are more talented than your faves.