Quote:
Originally posted by DD420
The opinions on Rihanna's albums is going to differ widely from person to person on here. So, to bring a little bit of an unbiased opinion (or as close to it as you can get), I've enlisted the help of Metacritic and AllMusic:
Metacritic: (out of 100)
Good Girl Gone Bad - 72
Rated R - 75
Loud - 67
AllMusic: (out of 5)
Good Girl Gone Bad - 4.5
Rated R - 4
Loud - 3
Average of Both Sites: (out of 100)
Good Girl Gone Bad - 81
Rated R - 77.5
Loud - 63.5
One could make an argument that Rihanna's quality is dipping as she released more and more music at a rapid rate. I'm not going to make that call, but the numbers are there for discussion.
|
AllMusic is a single review site though, isn't it? It's a little unfair to average an amalgamation of 20 review scores with another review score just to try to prove your point.
Just use Metacritic. According to Metacritic, Rated R is her best album (damn right).
Loud was a weaker album (due to the lack of personal connection IMO), but was still fine.
You're arguing that GGGB is better than Rated R, based on shoddy math.