The haters just need to accept that this is exceeding their expectations. Unless of course, they still consider her the #1 Pop girl and had higher expectations than her fans.

Fair enough, but Gaga has not only one or two, but three songs discounted on iTunes. The numbers are not great, they are just a result of three songs being discounted.

Has that ever been done before? Like ever?

On top of that Rihanna released her album in January.

~210K pure sales and ~265K SPS after two weeks. It's coming for 300K SPS in its third week I hope

She has 2. Perfect Illusion isn't discounted.

drag a bit

Sis did this make sense in your head

2

This era will sell less albums, singles and overall records than Rihanna's, Katy's, Taylor's or beyonce's latest or next records.
Bookmark me.

Not even you believe that



----
OGHs just can't win I love it

Discounted yet.... only one is/was top 10. Track sales do so much. The streams are still fairly good. The album is #2 on iTunes. She's doing pretty fine.

Literally none of them are on the radio and Carpool Karaoke was a week ago today while MR is still in and out of the Top 10

But y'all constantly call these albums major flops.

Ms. Swift will have a lot of fun with one of those names

Girl, I expected more from this era. She was/performed everywhere earlier including Grammys, Oscars, SuperBowl, Golden Globes, AHS, Billboard's Woman of the Year, Emmys etc etc. It's not like she's on the same level as Rihanna or Meghan Trainor (I mean, she's way bigger than both).

Only two were

Not Joanne ended up as a more-likely second best-selling female album of 2016 lmao. This is honestly a surprise to me as the only song I like is Dancing in Circles.

I think the female album Trinity of 2016 so far: Lemonade >>>>>> Joanne >> Encore (or whatever Barb's album name is)

Anti sold significantly less in the first week and now Joanne is doing similar numbers *a few thousand units more* in the second week, so I don't know what you're trying to prove...

And shouldn't Gaga be compared to the likes of Beyonce, Taylor Swift and Adele if she's an established pop girl? Why Ariana and Meghan?

The "But you guys say this" posts need to be backed up with receipts. It sounds a bit ridiculous considering it could have been one poster saying that.

Decent #s, but ANTI did 96k second week.

Sales are the pits