Umbrella is more remembered.

Umbrella >>>>>

The one that sold 15M, got 10M views last month, re-entered BB EDM chart 2 weeks ago and on top of that went DIAMOND 7 years after its release.

Poker Face

Not even a hard question.

Umbrella....

Oh please, don't kid yourselves. It's obviously Poker Face.

I heard Poker Face on the bus ride to a leadership convention a couple weeks ago, and everyone was singing along and poking each others faces. It was truly something to see as a Gaga stan. I've also heard it a few times since then.

I haven't heard Umbrella in months.

Both songs are legendary it doesn't get any higher than that.

PF was statistically bigger, but impact is what's important and both songs had a lot of that.

Both songs are highly recognizable and remembered.

Bigger hit : Poker Face
Most remembered : Umbrella

Hmmm I wonder if the monsters that were right to choose umbrella over fireworks in that other thread would have the common sense to pick the right one once again.... umbrella is more remembered more iconic. Poker face like most gaga songs sadly has aged so terribly!

Umbrella. Bigger and much more remembered, I haven't heard the other in ages.

mess

Umbrella is bigger AND more remembered.

And for once, GaGa ISN'T winning a poll that it didn't deserve to.