There is no good reason for ANY OF US to open any gifts that may appear in this game. First of all, you just saw what happened to genetic: we're going to be down THREE family members by the start of Day 2.
Secondly, we're the majority: Urban's immunity has no use for the majority faction, but more significance for the Elves and Krampus. Plus now the Elves know NOT to attack Urban, complicating him if he happens to be a Grandpa Hank role. It also doesn't allow us to vote him out, our SOLE means of power in this game.
4 Presents have been auctioned off via Random Number Generator, and they are as follows:
Spoiled Egg Nog - Kills one person; killer will NOT be revealed.
Garland - Strangles one person; killer WILL be revealed thanks to Little Eddie's forensics kit.
Snow Shovel - Saves the wielder from one public vote.
Snow Boots - Allows the wielder to hide in the shed out back, protecting them from the Evil Elves.
More presents will be sent out tonight, those who have one won't be eligible to receive another.