Hey Mama completely overshadowed it. Although I doubt it would have smashed even if Hey Mama wasn't popular at the time because it's pretty generic pure pop.
Its honestly as basic as any pop she'd made on Roman Reloaded, so if it were 2012 it would've been on the same level as Pound the Alarm or something i'd assume. Which is to say it would be a lukewarm hit and trail off never to be played again.