Movie: Rogue Cut from DOFP #downwithBryanSinger - Page 2

- JED -

Wut?

konaa

Good. Anna's a serviceable actress, but this ~interpretation~ of Rogue was awful. Between her obnoxious naiveté and giving up her powers, not for herself, but for a man's waning affection, Singer clearly has no idea who Rogue is.

He also ruined Cyclops, Jean and Wolverine, but.

Quote:

Originally posted by gio88

anyway i would have cut form the movie iceman and shadowcat and finally have gambit togheter with Rogue , considering they are much more important and famous on x-men universe than the first two...

nnn; what? Rogue and Gambit haven't been relevant since the nineties. Rogue had a brief surge of popularity into the millennium thanks to the first film and X-Men: Evolution, but hardly enough to call her important.

Kitty is arguably more important due to the fact she's the star of the Days of Future Past story line, one of the most iconic stories in comic book history that is still being ripped off today, mind you, and was the driving force behind Joss Whedon's critically acclaimed (and fan-favorite) Astonishing X-Men run.

EarlyMorning

Quote:

Originally posted by konaa

Good. Anna's a serviceable actress, but this ~interpretation~ of Rogue was awful. Between her obnoxious naiveté and giving up her powers, not for herself, but for a man's waning affection, Singer clearly has no idea who Rogue is.

He also ruined Cyclops, Jean and Wolverine, but.

nnn; what? Rogue and Gambit haven't been relevant since the nineties. Rogue had a brief surge of popularity into the millennium thanks to the first film and X-Men: Evolution, but hardly enough to call her important.

Kitty is arguably more important due to the fact she's the star of the Days of Future Past story line, one of the most iconic stories in comic book history that is still being ripped off today, mind you, and was the driving force behind Joss Whedon's critically acclaimed (and fan-favorite) Astonishing X-Men run.

These lies. Rogue has ALWAYS been a staple and relevant character, she's saved the team more times than I can count and her powers have advanced to a level in which some writers on the Marvel team have considered making her an Omega level mutant but have been too lazy to do such. Kitty on the other hand only gained relevance because of her pet dragon, ****in Cyclops, phasing that missile through earth and being the lead in the X-Men Evolution series. Don't do Rogue baby.

EarlyMorning

Quote:

Originally posted by Boomer

!!!
Which is why I'm not distaught over this. Half the reason we all like Rogue is because she is a badass with an attitude (in the comics & tv series').
They made her so meek in the movies.

Yeah but the main reason I was ready for this was because Rogue was supposed to be getting her ACTUAL powers in this. but they keep Halle's flop ass instead who can't even do **** because she's pregnant like the logic….

Kings.

In heard the film has some reshoots to do and Rogue might be in the final product, not sure if this is true or not

Source: http://www.comicbookmovie.com/fansit.../news/?a=91909

gio88

Quote:

Originally posted by konaa

Good. Anna's a serviceable actress, but this ~interpretation~ of Rogue was awful. Between her obnoxious naiveté and giving up her powers, not for herself, but for a man's waning affection, Singer clearly has no idea who Rogue is.

He also ruined Cyclops, Jean and Wolverine, but.

nnn; what? Rogue and Gambit haven't been relevant since the nineties. Rogue had a brief surge of popularity into the millennium thanks to the first film and X-Men: Evolution, but hardly enough to call her important.

Kitty is arguably more important due to the fact she's the star of the Days of Future Past story line, one of the most iconic stories in comic book history that is still being ripped off today, mind you, and was the driving force behind Joss Whedon's critically acclaimed (and fan-favorite) Astonishing X-Men run.

you can see rogue poularity even in teh animated version of the series! kitty pryde is famous just in some arc of x-men , rogue is known by everyone, even if she hasn' t big role in a specific series

just to do an example ...min 2.23 she is even mentioned here!

Dark Miracles

Rogue is popular for everything but these movies, she is almost useless in the film franchise because for some reason they stripped her of her awesome powers and gave her that power absorb ability instead. The scene sounded quite cool though from that description.

Scabandplaster

Byeeeeeeeeee.

gio88

Quote:

Originally posted by EarlyMorning

These lies. Rogue has ALWAYS been a staple and relevant character, she's saved the team more times than I can count and her powers have advanced to a level in which some writers on the Marvel team have considered making her an Omega level mutant but have been too lazy to do such. Kitty on the other hand only gained relevance because of her pet dragon, ****in Cyclops, phasing that missile through earth and being the lead in the X-Men Evolution series. Don't do Rogue baby.

AMEN!

everyone that knows x-men (even a little) knows about Cyclops , Xavier , Wolverine , Storm , Jean Grey and Rogue and enemies Magneto and Mystique , the others are not THAT popular! there is no way kitty pryde is more important than rogue in x-men unvierse!

James Maslow

What the hell!

MP2K

They always play Rogue and Storm in these films. When will this ever end?

DreamOn

1. The films do not do the girls any justice whatsoever except Mystique Rebecca. Rogue in the films is bland. They just got the essence of the series and comic book character of her absorbing energy and power. Not even the flying and the kick ass moves and the spunky personality

2.WTF 1 sequence for her?Like what can we expect for other minor yet awesome characters?

3. Now that I've watched Angela Bassett on Coven. Halle is the pits

4.I'm done with the films showing Hugh Jackman 95% of the time when he doesn't represent the X-men as whole. And he's getting uglier by each film it aint cute

5.I am done with Bryan Singer and his ambitious geeky ass.

BlooRiverAnimal

I love Rogue, but if she wasn't going to have a significant part in the film then I see why they cut it. Anyway, I am a bit pressed about it, but it is what it is.

------

In all honesty, if anyone should have been cut; should've been Wolverine's overrated ass.

BlooRiverAnimal

Quote:

Originally posted by MP2K

They always play Rogue and Storm in these films. When will this ever end?

They downplay Storm so much in the films. Like, where is her power? Still pressed she got her ass beat by Toad in X1.

Razzle

Aww that sucks

rivers

This sucks!!

Poor Anna Paquin even did comic con with the cast. At least that was the only promo she did with them.

Dark Miracles

Quote:

Originally posted by BlooRiverAnimal

They downplay Storm so much in the films. Like, where is her power? Still pressed she got her ass beat by Toad in X1.

By Toad in X1, by that fast girl in X3,...

She hardly ever wins.

Elec†ricJudas

She adds NOTHING to the franchise at all so I really don't care. Bryan Singer always pays his female cast absolute dust and i'm sick of it.

gio88

i really hope she will have a mjor role in 2016 x-men:apocalyse , but at this point i don't know...she is constantly the most underrated character in the franchise , she simply should kick some ass!

gio88

probably it's just me but i hope Wolverine won't come back for the next x-men movie , I think it's enough for him having his own franchise and being the main proatgonist of the x-men movies , it' time give more space to other characters , even because i think everything that could be said about him it has been already said!(considering that just 3 movies , 2 from x-men and 1 from wolvering origins are about his past!), and anyway i never thought his character was so much interesting!