Her American Idol performance is so overrated, sorry
Her high notes were great there, her technique was probably great aswell, but it's not only about that.
It's also about how it sounds alltogether, and Demi sounded screechy in the low parts, her voice was out of control there. It was also way too breathy. And she had problems hitting the low notes ("realize..." )
Imo
VMAs=katie >>> American Idol > MTV NYE >> GMA >>>> Today >>>>>>>> PCAs
i mean, in my opinion we are just over analizing her as a technical vocalist. The thing is, no one is going to sit in front of the TV and say "oh wow, her vibrato was a bit better than on her last performance, but less good than at that time"
