Yeah, as proven by Fefe Dobson swagger jacking situation combined with lack of input in songs during GGGB era

rihanna and katy are manufactured in different ways

rihanna I believe has some kind of input in her image and "theme" of an era, her personality it's truly hers and even though she doesn't have almost any input in her songs she chooses which songs are part of the album (as we seen in the talk that talk videos that were shown prior the release of the album)

katy on the other hand writes her own songs and has her own ideas but i don't think she has much power when it comes to making decitions as we que can see in this bonnie mckee interview :

source: http://fashionindie.com/interview-bonnie-mckee/

as you can see katy has creative input but is not her decition at the end of the day

Its sad that when someone says something critical about Gaga, he is always considered a hater or marked as jealous. Its just my observation.

For your info, I have posted my opinion about who is manufactured and I havent mentioned Gaga.

Rita Ora just seems very manufactured to me.

Katy and Lana

Rihanna

Katy, Rihanna

Rihanna and all those K-Pop groups.

I love Britney to dead, but as long as the thread says "at the moment" I must say that britney cause she is not taking control of her career really, so sad but truth, other than her, must be... I think Katy Perry, and I dont know about kesha, is just that I heard a ballad from her, I dont know the name, and it was awesome, but she come with her party songs so that sounds to me manufactured, and for god sake, JUSTIN MANUFACIEBER is on my top, I think Rihanna and Beyonce are by little out of this, and Lady Gaga is so far from being manufactured, she works hard, and there is the confussion :Guitarra:

I agree with this

can u guys tell me what ur defintion of manufactured is because for me its someone who dosent write ther own music,dosent really have a distinct personality,dosent do or say anything controversial, isnt too creative image wise...meaning they stay the same,no parental advisory sticker,and it wouldnt feel akward taking someone under 13 to their concert........to me that is someone like justin beiber, one direction, britney spears,katy perry (maybe), kelly clarkston,brandy career until now

dont understand how rihanna is manufactured...i mean so she dosent have a writing credit but if she was manufactured like she was until really the end of gggb she wouldnt have released rated r,loud,or talk that talk, she wouldnt have a twitter,she wouldnt have gone on oprah,she wouldnt sing birthday cake, and wouldnt do a big image change every album.........like what are yall seeing, gaga and beyonce clerly arent either

What you need to realize is that "bad girls" can be just as much manufactured as Disney acts. Why wouldn't a label want to cash in and exploit the most attention grabbing event in their star career? Let her swear on tracks, public will love this, the money will roll. When it didn't quite work out they set up writing camp for Loud really quick. Rihanna had no part in the writing process, she choose producers and then showed up when material was ready.

Jessie J.